A rise in HMRC Notices of Requirement for Security: more cases, more losses
Last updated 13 Nov 2026 , by InTAX Ltd
Notices of Requirement for Security (NoRs) can be issued by HMRC for risks associated with the payment of taxes.
HMRC may issue NoRs regarding PAYE/NICs/CIS, as well as for VAT. In practice, they are a demand for a person or business to provide a security deposit to HMRC against future tax liabilities.
For PAYE notices, HMRC can also make the directors jointly liable. As NoRs can result in criminal sanctions, they are a very serious issue for businesses and individuals.
Responding incorrectly, continuing to trade, or failing to meet a payment deadline may lead to criminal investigation and criminal penalties.
What does the data show?
We wrote an article in 2023, which can be found here, about the upsurge in NoRs issued by HMRC.
Under a previous freedom of information (FOI) request to HMRC, the number of NoRs issued was as follows:
| Year | PAYE/NICs | VAT |
| 2020/21 | 428 | 479 |
| 2021/22 | 731 | 792 |
| 2022/23 | 1291 | 1193 |
An updated request for recent years revealed the following numbers:
| Year | PAYE/NICs | VAT |
| 2023/24 | 1523 | 1798 |
| 2024/25 | 1562 | 2090 |
| 2025/26 | 2268 | 2678 |
The recent FOI request demonstrates that the upsurge has continued, with a marked uptick in the 2025/26 tax year.
The data reflects our own experience, as we have been instructed to appeal more NoRs over the last few years than ever before.
The Tribunal’s changing attitude to Notices of Requirement
NoRs are a powerful tool, allowing HMRC to tackle repeated phoenixism. We support HMRC having the tools available to discourage this behaviour and make directors responsible for poor behaviour.
However, HMRC also appears to be using NoRs as a ‘debt collection’ mechanism.
In many cases, HMRC is issuing these to companies which have found themselves in difficult trading conditions, rather than companies that are deliberately running up debts which they intend to ‘walk away’ from.
In tribunal, HMRC has repeatedly argued that it is irrelevant whether a NoR automatically places a company or company director in default due to their financial difficulty. Nonetheless, a recent tribunal decision suggests otherwise.
In the recent case of Crescendo Entertainment Ltd v HMRC, the tribunal found that a taxpayer’s ability to pay, including considerations of hardship and proportionality, is a relevant factor when determining whether a NoR is necessary for the protection of the revenue.
This decision represents a departure from HMRC’s position that a recipient’s financial circumstances do not play a part when deciding whether to pursue security.
Judge Popplewell agreed with the reasoning adopted in the recent NoR Tribunal cases of Duma and D-Media.
What to do if you receive a Notice of Requirement?
If you are threatened with a NoR, or have received one, it is important to seek advice as soon as possible.
Simply ignoring a NoR can lead to severe legal and financial consequences, with the potential for criminal sanctions, so early specialist intervention is needed to minimise penalties.
In addition, a NoR does not automatically get forgotten when a company enters liquidation, particularly if the liability is tied to a specific director.
We can evaluate whether a NoR has been issued legitimately, challenge HMRC’s reasoning and negotiate the level of security demanded.
In our experience, these cases can often be resolved without needing a tribunal hearing, so please contact our specialists for further guidance.
You can get in touch with our friendly and experienced team on: 0203 675 8122 or email info@inTAXltd.com.
inTAX is a specialist tax disputes firm. We deal with disclosures, investigations, and tax enquiries of all descriptions, including COP9, fraud investigations, VAT fraud, tax avoidance, let property disclosures and tribunal appeals. However, we don’t just deal with the serious end of tax investigations; we are also happy to handle smaller enquiries, disputes and problems that can be equally as worrying for our clients.